J. Neil Schulman
@ Agorist.com
@ Agorist.com
This might not be apparent to those of you who know me only by word. Also, if you’ve met me in person, in the right decade, you could have known me when I was thin. There was a time I wore size 32 waist/34 length slacks and a 40 Long jacket.
I don’t need a reminder that I’m fat. I remember it quite well every time I get up from a chair or look in the bathroom mirror.
But I was reminded that I’m fat when an old pal of mine from my AnarchoVillage days — fellow Prometheus-laureate Victor Koman, perhaps best known for his 1996 novel (of which I was the first publisher) Kings of the High Frontier, recently published a new book titled Dr. K’s Sure-Fire Instant Weight-Loss Secrets.
Unusually, Koman simultaneously released his book not as an audiobook but as a videobook you can watch free on YouTube.
Spoiler Warning: Dr. K has only one “sure-fire instant weight-loss secret.” It’s “Eat less, exercise more!”
I’ve known Victor Koman since 1975. At no time in the 34 years I’ve known Victor Koman was he ever fat. Oh, he might have put on a few pounds in recent years when due to knee problems he couldn’t be as active as he used to be, but even at his most sedentary it never would have crossed my mind to think of him as fat.
Victor Koman was not fat the last time I saw him in person in spring of this year. Victor Koman is not fat appearing in the brand-new videobook edition of Dr. K’s Sure-Fire Instant Weight-Loss Secrets.
If you’re going to buy a book on weight-loss (or a funny book on the subject of weight loss) an author’s photo of Victor Koman will sell a hell of a lot more copies than an author’s photo of me.
If our face was the same, I’m the “before” picture and Victor Koman is the “after” picture.
I’m the Biggest Loser they show you in the promos. Victor Koman is the guy they trot out hugging everyone on the season finale.
Now, don’t get me wrong. Viewed as a thermodynamic paradigm, Victor Koman is absolutely correct about his weight-loss secret. It’s sound chemistry and physics. Restricting the availability of fuel while simultaneously increasing the consumption of fuel, for any thermodynamic engine, will result in a net depletion of the fuel supply. The human body is a thermodynamic engine. Excess fuel is stored on the human body as fat. Restricting intake of new fuel while simultaneously increasing the consumption of stored fuel will deplete an engine’s stored fuel supply.
I’m not stupid. I’m also not particularly weak-willed. You can’t be weak-willed and several times in your lifetime stick to a regime of diet (under 1000 calories, under 40 grams carbohydrate) and exercise (both cardio and weight training) sufficient to lose over 100 pounds, and a dozen other times lose over 50 pounds, plus faithfully sticking to Weight Watchers for over six months which resulted in a loss of only ten pounds. For several years of my life I walked over three miles every day. For close to a year I worked out at Bally’s for an hour four days a week.
I’ve also written books — including three novels which each took me years to complete. I also have written scripts and articles to deadline, and wrote, directed, produced, and post-produced an independent film. I also entrepreneured several businesses for years at a time. I’m not known as a quitter.
Yet, I’m fat. I suffer from Type II Diabetes, a disease that would be better controlled were I to become thinner.
Why hasn’t Victor Koman’s thermodynamic weight-loss secret worked to keep me fit?
This isn’t a problem just for me. Obesity has become more the rule than the exception in the United States and other parts of the developed world. Pundits blame fast foods, sugary drinks, candy machines, kids texting and playing with their Wii’s rather than biking and jumping rope, and of course the inevitable laments that the taxpayers aren’t being sucked dry enough to pay for school and after-school physical education and sports.
Look. I hardly ever eat fast food. I don’t eat candy. I don’t consume drinks with calories in them. When I eat dessert it’s Sugar Free Popsicles, Sugar Free Jello, and no-fat/no-sugar added “ice cream.” The bread I eat has 40 calories a slice and has low net carbs. I take the skin off my chicken and eat as much fish (not breaded and fried!) as I can afford.
I know how to diet. I’ve done it my entire life.
I know how to exercise. I know about cardio and weight-training and stretching.
I’ve tried diet aids and diet foods and diet supplements and diet plans. My body can’t tolerate most diet aids. They’re either stimulants that give me a racing and sometimes irregular heartbeat or they’re blockers that give me chronic lower-intestinal problems. (I won’t be more graphic than that.)
Durk Pearson, Sandy Shaw, and Will Block are personal friends I’ve talked to about my health problems, and I regularly read Life Enhancement. I’ve tried most of their recommended supplementing.
I’ve also had “the talk” with every primary-care physician who’s treated me over the years.
We’ve eliminated hypothyroidism as the cause of my weight gain.
I keep up with biological research. I read about genetic body types — ectomorphs, endomorphs, and mesomorphs — and genetic propensities to weight gain based on one’s ancestry. I read about ghrelin/leptin cycles, and lab experiments being done on rats. I read about theories that obesity can possibly be an actual disease spread by a virus.
Is obesity caused by a disease or a series of bad lifestyle habits? Is overeating an addiction like alcohol or cocaine?
If I’m so smart and strong-willed, why am I still fat?
Why, indeed?
I can tell you this much. I am deconditioned. At my current weight any attempt to exert myself runs the risk of overexertion leading to hyperventilation. Attempts to exercise result in painful muscle cramping.
Every attempt to restrict food intake makes me lethargic and sleepy.
In other words: my body appears to have a will of its own. It fights me and hurts me when I try to “Eat less, exercise more!”
Matching my ancedotal data, the medical research shows that 95% of patients who lose weight regain it within five years. Medical science has less of a handle on dieting and health than it does on how to treat cancer.
Diet and exercise is so ineffective a long-term treatment for so many obese patients that many doctors won’t even prescribe it anymore, and if you read medical literature as I’ve done you discover that invasive and often painful bariatric surgery — followed by weeks of a liquid diet then by a diet more restrictive than any I used to lose hundreds of pounds — is the only medical treatment doctors are willing to recommend to their severely obese patients.
Late-night TV has a lot of commercials and infomercials for various diet plans — Weight Watchers, Jenny Craig, Nutrasystem, cookie diets — plus no end of diet supplements. There isn’t a single one that doesn’t sport a disclaimer something like, “Results Not Typical.”
Yeah. How far would a car manufacturer get if next to the city and highway mileage figure on the sticker it had the disclaimer, “Results not typical”?
So what’s my recommendations for weight-loss success? Eat less and exercise more — if your body doesn’t try to kill you doing it.
And please, could the next Jonas Salk come up with an effective, non-invasive, and not painful or cognitively adverse treatment for obesity which doesn’t need that damned disclaimer?
Here’s one thing the AMA won’t tell you. Back when almost everybody smoked — and those were also the days when everybody typically ate butter, cheese, and red meat as staples — obesity, Diabetes, and even heart disease were far less common.
I suspect nicotine might be the cure for obesity, but who’s going to fund the research?
Maybe I should just pull a Nutty Professor on myself and even though I’m not a smoker try the nicotine patch.
But I’m just not that brave.
As for my recommendation for Victor Koman, it’s that his next book be Dr. K’s Sure-Fire Secrets For Getting Rich Quick.
It should consist of twenty chapters of Victor Koman recommending, “Buy low, sell high!”
November 10, 2009 - 9:26 am
Yes, I remember when you weren’t fat, and I remember when you got fat, and I know that once the body gets fat it usually decides it wants to stay fat. But since we can’t turn the clock back to the time before the fat, I guess I’ll just have to pray for you, and hope that helps.
November 10, 2009 - 10:59 am
Neil–great post! I knew some of what you’ve gone through, but to read the whole story is gut-wrenching indeed. Obviously, the book is a parody of all the other weight-loss writers out there whose advice really does boil down to those two steps. And you can get the same advice in paperback for $6.95, instead of in hardback for $29.95! I wish you good luck and good health, and hope that you can find some way to control the diabetes and lead a long, full life.
November 10, 2009 - 11:55 am
And you anticipated my next book! Damn your eyes!
November 10, 2009 - 1:42 pm
Thanks to Jared Lobdell for his prayers and to Victor Koman for his atheistic “wish.”
After I released my article Yahoo News linked a new Time article from Monday titled “Teen Obesity: Lack of Exercise May Not Be to Blame.” The latest medical research says rates of teen activity haven’t significantly decreased in the last two decades while rates of teen obesity have soared.
You can read the Time article here.
Neil
November 11, 2009 - 6:57 am
Good story. I have a few crackpot theories of my own (about obesity). I recently read that placebos have become as effective as SSRI’s (Prozac etc.). Also, butter didn’t used to be a staple, it was too expensive. During WWII even lard was hard to come by. And then we had margarine. My current theory is “information overload”: people with too many interests eat too much.
November 11, 2009 - 2:06 pm
People in the USA are fat.
People in (say) Dafur are thin.
You could always try moving
November 11, 2009 - 3:20 pm
You could do what I did to lose about 30 pounds (242 to 210): have your mitral valve repaired followed a year and a half later by gall bladder removal.
But I have kept it off for the last year and a half by intermittant fasting. Don’t know whether that would work for you, but it’s doing it for me.
Don’t eat two days a week and make it to the club 2 or 3 times for an hour of weights and cardio.
November 11, 2009 - 8:29 pm
I too have struggled all my life. I went on a ‘Quick weight loss center” beginning in 87, lost a couple hundred pounds, gained it all back over the course of fifteen years, had a lap-band surgery, which took me from 400+ to about 320 which is where I’m kinda stalled. I’m gonna go get another adjustment after the first of the year and try to get back on the way down again, and my knees wish I was doing it NOW. Best of luck. No, there are no good answers. It is a vicious cycle and there doesn’t seem to be anyone doing anything meaningful. All the drugs have been troublesome. All the exercise/diet programs are annoying. To hell with the moon;inertia is a harsh mistress.
One thing I have found that helps me, somewhat, is having someone to do something with that i like doing that is gently aerobic. If you can find someone who likes to walk, say 1 hour a day, and go someplace different on a regular basis to take those walks. I lose weight readily when I hunt, but I can’t do it every day. it’s not magic and it’s not quick but it’s something. Exercise for the sake of exercise is vile. Like diet food.
November 12, 2009 - 7:03 pm
A story in today’s Los Angeles Times titled
“Bacteria in intestines play role key role in weight gain, study finds” tells us that, “Many factors play a role in the propensity to gain weight, including genetics, physical activity and the environment, as well as food choices. But a growing body of evidence, much of it accumulated by Dr. Jeffrey I. Gordon of Washington University in St. Louis, shows that bacteria in the gut also play a key role.”
Thanks to David M. Klaus for the email linking the story.
July 2, 2012 - 12:21 am
Sleep apnea can be a factor. And staying up late even if you compensate by sleeping in is supposed to be one of the “unusual” suspects.
July 2, 2012 - 1:46 pm
Love when people try remote-control diagnosis.
Nope.
July 8, 2012 - 2:03 pm
I can’t recall thinking you were fat when I visited the AnarchoVillage in the early 1970s, so you probably weren’t. . .
Have you tried the Atkins Diet? It is a miracle. I have gone on it twice and both times lost about 35 lbs in a few months by stopping completely the intake of starch and sugar (including fruit) and eating whenever I am moved to do so, but only meat, eggs, sausage, bacon, nuts, cheese, and non-sweet vegetables like broccoli, caulflower, salad greens, etc. Both times my cholesterol plummeted CONTRARY to the expectations of Rockefeller controlled medicine. By the way, it is important to monitor the keytones in your blood to assure yourself that you are burning fat and carbs aren’t somehow creeping back into your diet.
This time, I think I’ll stay on the diet. Last time, I fell to my sugar and starch habit by starting a little cheating here and there.
I know dozen of people by the way who ballooned in weight after they stopped smoking.
July 8, 2012 - 2:05 pm
I do think the Atkins Diet can be dangerous when you cheat. . . if you eat more carbs than you need to burn, then the fat from the Atkins Diet piles up. . . Without excessive carbs, the body can handle fat and protein.
July 8, 2012 - 2:10 pm
By the way, many people report diabetes is no longer a problem after they’ve been on the Atkins Diet for a time. . . no wonder! Nothing much for the insulin to do. . . gives it a real rest.
My arthritis got a lot better when I got back on Atkins, but I am not cured.
July 8, 2012 - 2:14 pm
Oh, just for reference purposes, my weight was about 265. . . dropped to 230. To meet the Rockefeller mandated weight, I guess I’d have to exercise and learn to eat less.
July 8, 2012 - 2:16 pm
Woops, you don’t have to monitor the keytones in your blood. That costs $$$$. You can monitor it in your urine with cheap little test strips.
November 10, 2012 - 7:52 am
Greate pieces. Keep writing such kind of info on your
site. Im really impressed by your blog.
Hey there, You have performed a great job. I will certainly digg it and for
my part suggest to my friends. I am sure they will be benefited from this website.